c

 

A Practical Indian Philosophy

 

 

 

 



34    Chaupaayi:    Kahata nasaa-yi ho-yi hiya neekee: reejhata Raama jaani jana-jee-kee:: 
Rahati na Prabhu-chita chooka ki-yay kee: karata surati sa-ya-baara hi-yay kee:: Bk29

34.     Tulaseedaasa continues, "Talking of one's devotion or goodness destroys it. My prayer may appear good or bad, but Shree Raama appreciates the devotees' intent, forgets their lapses and remembers their devotion a hundred times." (See Geetaa 4:11) 

        Just as love determines the spirituality in thought, word or deed in religions, intent, not its result, determines the correctness of a deed. To be alert to our intent is the first discipline for us lest we trip into errors. The overwhelming power of six passions in us gives quality to our intent and causes all our errors. It makes a useful discussion into a fruitless argument and turns constructive communication into destructive pastime. When introspection and contemplation in solitude may not be frequent with us, this alertness to our intent saves us. 

        The second scriptural lesson Tulaseedaasa brings out is that God appreciates our good intent a hundredfold for showering His grace in the same manner as one seed, namely, our intent or act produces a million fruit. This means that if we take one step towards God He takes a hundred towards us to expedite our progress towards Him. If not, we deny our faith in Him as love personified for our intimate relationship for our good. (See 239, 246

       The third lesson is that neither the language of our prayer, an excellent hymn, nor the mere repetition of God's name matters. God knows our intent and fulfils it if it is sincere, virtuous and in our best interest. 

        Before this couplet, Tulaseedaasa says: 

34A    Chaupaayi:    Ati barhi mori ddhitthaa-yee khoree: suni agha narakahu naaka sikoree:: Bk29

        Tulaseedaasa says, "It is my obstinacy that I treat myself as the servant of such a great master. The stench of my sins makes even hell plug its nose." Tulaseedaasa’s past made him panic-stricken. This however never entered Shree Raama's mind even in his dream. A question arises. How could Tulaseedaasa know that God ignored his errors? Tulaseedaasa is merely stating a precept of Sanaatana Dharma. 

        God is the personification of love of a mother. It is His Satchidaananda nature to be happy as a mother in our enjoying innocent bliss. So that we all reach Him as our destination, He ignores our errors and helps us to get rid of them. (See 19, 205 and Geetaa 5:15, 9:18) Taking note of bad qualities would sway God against the devotee. So, the worse our error, the greater God's desire to redeem us. (See 275, 347) If we commit errors, God gives repeated opportunities in life to correct ourselves and, if insufficient, a rebirth as a continuing opportunity. Every soul is one with Him. A being cannot remain away from its origin for all time in perdition. (See Geetaa 7:6) A sin is merely our error in ignorance caused by God's maya. In God's jurisprudence, our ignorance is the very reason for our redemption. (See 252) God creates all good and bad amongst and around us. (See 239) How can He be angry with either or with the worst among us? We are advised that on our repentance, eschewing sin and surrender, God forgives us by wiping out impurities from our mind and the impact upon us of the consequences of our past errors. After this nothing is left in us for us to forgive ourselves. We are free. (See 185, 193

        A devotee of God can have a pure heart. Yet his word or deed can hurt someone unintentionally. God appreciates the purity of the devotee's intent. Preceding this couplet is 

34B    Chaupaayi:     Reejhata Raama sanayha nisautayn: ko jaga manda malina-mati mau-tayn::  Bk28

        Tulaseedaasa says, "Shree Raama is pleased with the unalloyed love of devotion. But dull-witted and impure in mind" as I am, I often forget it.

34C    Chhanda: Prabhu bhaava-gaahaka, ati kripaala, saprayma suni sukha maanaheen:: Uk 92

        Kaakabhushunddi said to Garurha, "As a keen customer, Shree Raama recognizes only His devotee's attitude towards Him. He is kind and derives happiness from listening to love for Him." (See 444 and Geetaa 9:26-27) 

        We can express our deep devotion to God in the 'Thou' and 'I' relationship in at least these attitudes and feelings towards Him. Shaanta, the serene, is the attitude of the rishis who simply contemplated upon God and desired nothing from Him except to attain Him. This is an attitude of surrender to God and acceptance of what comes as His grace. Daasya is the attitude of a voluntary slave of the master. Sakhya is loyal friendship. Vatsalya, is mother's love for her child. Madhura is a chaste woman's love of her husband or the sweetness of the love of a pure heart. This last attitude towards God secures for us the highest in bliss. (See 101, 360) In any of these attitudes, it is obvious that our faults cannot sway God. If we sincerely stick to any of these attitudes, we get rid of our faults too. 

        If devotion to God is motivated by show, worldly enjoyment, expectation of respect or prestige, it is raajasic as Raavana's was. If it is motivated by arrogance and selfishness causing blindness of anger, it is taamasic as Kumbhakaran's was. If it is motivated by selfless love and service of all as the service of God, it is saatvic as Vibheeshan's was. (See 27) God is for all with their variety of natures and faults. This couplet emphasizes that God looks for its intent and ignores the form of prayer. Being the embodiment of love, He responds by His heart to the call of our heart in our inadequately worded prayer. (See 262

        The second couplet brings out that Shree Raama sees the intent behind the deed, selfish or selfless and good or bad, as its touchstone. The same act can hurt one and help another. Also, it is neither the act (a painful surgical operation) nor its result (death of the patient) that matters. This is because all acts are inert and qualityless in themselves in the same way as any phenomenon of nature. Our intent gives our acts their quality. Since we cannot control any results, only our good intent attracts Shree Raama's grace. (See 72, 444

       It is better that we keep our devotion within ourselves. 

34D    Chaupaayi:     Chheejahin nisichara dina aru raatee: nija mukha kahay sukrita jayhi bhaantee:: Lk72

        Shiva said to Paarvatee, "The demons became weaker day and night in the same way as good deeds, such as charity, sacrifice or devotion, are destroyed by our talking about them." Verbalizing is prompted by pride, which destroys that on which pride is based. (See 413

        The lesson is to forget and never speak to anyone of the good we ever do. This good includes our spiritual discipline, devotion, selfless deeds of benevolence and charity. We should always thank God for enabling us to be and do good and should seek from Him more opportunities and capacity for good deeds. Under the law of karma, good deeds make our life fulfilling and blissful, which can only be experienced. (A Lesson in Good Conduct) 

35    Chaupaayi:     Sambhu keenha yaha charita sohaavaa: bahuri kripaa kari Umaahin sunaavaa:: 
So-yi Siva Kaagabhushunddihi deenhaa: Raaama-bhagata adhikaaree cheenhaa:: 
Tayhi sana Jaagabalika puni paavaa: tinha puni Bharadwaaja munii gaavaa:: Bk 30

35.     Tulaseedaasa continues, "Shiva first narrated Shree Raama's Story to Paarvatee. Considering Kaakabhushunddi, the crow, Shree Raama's deserving devotee, Shiva also narrated the Story to him. Yaajnavalkya heard it from Kaakabhushunddi and told it to Bharadwaaja."

        In addition to what he heard from his guru, Tulaseedaasa brought in these three narratives at places in the Book. The three narrators were Shree Raama's contemporaries. Birds, such as Kaakabhushunddi too can have devotion to God. (See 65[6], 267

       In the chapter Uttarakaandda of the Book, it is mentioned that Lomasha heard this Story as a gift from Shiva. Lomasha told the Story to Kaakabhushunddi, when he was a man in one of his earlier lives. 

        Some of the Indian scriptures are in the form of questions and answers. Shiva's answers to Paarvatee's questions become Raamaayana. (See 61, 469) Questions and answers explain the reasons underlying beliefs. Beliefs are one’s religion. The reasons form the philosophy of one’s religion. Philosophy strengthens shrad-dhaa for practice of religion by the faithful and shows light to the sceptic. Both in science and in matters of spirit and faith, all questions cannot be answered. In the latter, however, inexplicable matters of faith can be experienced, for example, the joy of living in virtue, which invokes God's grace to sustain us in crises. Our question should invariably intend to benefit all and should not be for our egoistic joy of its brilliance or unanswerability. (See 2 and Geetaa 10:41) 

36    Dohaa:     Raama ananta ananta guna amita kathaaa bistaara: 
Suni aacharaju na maanihahin jinha kay vimala bichaara:: Bk33

36.     Tulaseedaasa continues, "Shree Raama and his qualities are infinite. His story has no end. Only purified minds are not surprised by listening to it." (See Geetaa 10:40) 

        It is an axiom that only a man of purified mind can see God by His grace. No one can know God fully to narrate all about Him. (See 148, 318) The more pure the mind, the greater is our capacity to see miracles in the smallest phenomenon around us. The pure mind experiences God's omnipotence in doing impossible things. An example of such things is God’s appearing as a human Incarnation on the earth. Only a mind purified a little can recognize an Incarnation of God. In the Mahaabhaarata, Duryodhana, many Kauravas and others did not recognize Shree Krishna as God. The Paanddavas did. In the Ramayana even Parashuraama, himself a minor Incarnation of God (ansha avataara), could not recognize Shree Raama as an Incarnation of God (see (106) in the story). This was because anger polluted Parashuraama’s mind. The pure mind can believe the unending stories of the Incarnation's wonderful deeds. Those with minds polluted by passions, particularly ego, cannot believe that God can do more than what they can imagine or are accustomed to believe about Him. 

        The epithet mariyaadaa purushot-tama (acme of righteousness among men of noble tradition) is used for Shree Raama. It merely confirms a fact. Without being ideal in His conduct, an Incarnation of God cannot establish His being God and restore dharma among people by his imperfect example. In our ignorance of the totality of factors, including the impact of our past karma in us and of the tradition of His times, in a particular situation before Him, the conduct of an Incarnation of God appears to us today as faulty. It is not so. People follow example and not so much a precept. Every child watches parents and learns from their example more than by their teaching. Hence the Indian tradition is 'as the king so the people.' (See Geetaa 3:21) Shree Raama's ideal conduct and life distinguish Him from the highest among men to attract people and command their respect. Without either, He cannot complete His task. 

       For the pure rationalist, the epithet mariyaadaa purushot-tama does not indicate an Incarnation of God as an occurrence. For him Shree Raama is a fictitious king among men whose story is an attempt to put together all the virtues a man can display as an individual, as a King or as a member of a family. For non-believers, this or any other view is valid. (See 65[8, 9, 11], 411) Non-believers are also contemporaries of an Incarnation of God. Ignoring non-believers, contemporary believers as Guru Vasishttha and Paanddava Princes consider themselves fortunate because they recognized Shree Raama and Shree Krishna, respectively, to benefit from them. (See 269, 438) God shows other paths to non-believers because He loves all. (See Geetaa 4:11)

        Respecting God’s omnipresence, omnipotence and omniscience, Sanaatana Dharma also believes in the concept of ansha avataaras or partial Incarnations of God who sometimes also show a duality. They manifest divinity and human weaknesses both. All followers in their selective wisdom adopt their message or example in their former phase and ignore their conduct in the latter phase of their lives.  Some gurus also exhibit this duality. The message and conduct based on love and bliss for all manifests divinity and its opposite or bereft of it is to be and so is ignored by wise followers of ansha avataaras.

37    Chaupaayi:     Samvata soraaha sai ikteesaa: kara-un kathaa Haripada dhari seesaa:: 
Naumi bhauma-baara madhu maasaa: Avadha-puree yaha charita prakaasaa:: Bk34

37. Tulaseedaasa continues, "After placing my head in reverence at Shree Raama's feet, I write his Story. I begin it at Ayodhyaa, Uttar Pradesh, India, on the ninth, a Tuesday, of the mild lunar month of Chaitra of Vikrama Samvat 1631."

        Ayodhyaa is Shree Raama's birthplace. The date in the Indian calendar mentioned here is 30 March 1574, the anniversary of his birth. Tulaseedaasa gives this date of commencement of his Book. He did not give the date of completion of this work. He started writing it at the age of 77 if the traditional date of his birth is taken as 1497 and his death at Varanasi, India, in 1623. (Gita Press Edition, 2000) Some research makes 1532 as the more probable date of Tulaseedaasa’s birth. 

38    Chaupaayi:  Jayhi dina Raama-janama sruti gaavahin: teeratha sakala tahaan chali aavahin:: Bk34

38.     Tulaseedaasa continues, "It is said in the Vedas that on celebration of Shree Raama's birth anniversary, the spirits of all the places of pilgrimage gather at the place of the celebration." 

        Shree Raama's birthday is auspicious. Its celebration at home  secures His devotee the blessings, which he earns by a visit to all places of pilgrimage. The concept in the Vedas is that remembering God in whatever manner or by any virtuous means invites the merit of visiting all places of pilgrimage because these places also remind us of God. Tulseedaasa gives primacy to remembering the day but not to the place of Shree Raama’s birth. This is because the place of his birth in Traytaayuge hundreds of thousands of years ago cannot be determined with exactitude to build a temple at that site. (See 79

        It is also an auspicious day when we offer gratitude to God for His munificence to us. It is said that there are four auspicious days for this gratitude. One is when our brothers, sisters, relations or friends gather in a festive spirit. Another is when we avail of a chance for feeding the poor and hungry and for caring of the needy and the distressed. Another is when we can meditate upon God. The last is when we meet a spiritually advanced person to inspire us towards the higher life of the spirit. 

39    Chaupaayi:    Kaama koha mada moha nasaavana: bimala bibayka biraaga barrhaavana:: 
Saadara majjana paana ki-yay tayn: mittahin paapa paritaapa hi-yay tayn:: Bk43

39.      Treating Shree Raama's life story symbolically as a river, Tulaseedaasa continues, "If a man drinks its water, that is, studies it and bathes in it, that is, reverentially listens to it, then his desires, anger, the intoxication of pride, and his attachment to worldly objects, are destroyed. Instead, detachment or vairaagya and discrimination or vivayka grow in him and the impact upon him of his sins and suffering is destroyed." (See 185[16]) 

        Shree Raama lived in the innate purity of human nature and thereby showed human role and destiny in its divinity for all to emulate. The message of Shree Raama's life provides us the principles for the conduct of our life to achieve continual bliss. Our devotion to Shree Raama prompts us to understand this message by the study of His life story and discussion with knowledgeable persons in satyasanga. The illiterates listen to the story to get guideline for life from the narrators. The guidelines emphasize the need to get rid of our six passions by alertness. Passions derive power from our dwelling on and being attracted by objects around us. So, we withdraw our interest from the outside objects, which is Vairaagya. Vairaagya becomes easier when we sift our desires arising from objects to pick the worthwhile and reject the worthless. This sifting develops Vivayka or discrimination. Bhakti, vivayka and vairaagya qualify us for bliss in life and a vision of God. (See 210

        Shree Raama’s principles for our conduct become practical for us in the apparently stressful life today only if we have faith that if we follow His path, He will protect and nourish us. It is the ancient Indian precept that dharma protects those who protect dharma by living in it first and not by fighting for it. Dharma is our innate divine nature, which needs no protection for which to fight. Our body needs protection by dharma for living in it. Without this faith, Shree Raama’s path is impractical, as is the view of many today. When we talk of today’s stress we forget that every age has its stress, which reaches the brim of man’s capacity. This is to make man always strive his utmost to reach beyond where he has reached for his continuous advancement. Stresses of different ages cannot be compared. Yet man’s capacity is always more than the burden. The proof is in the survival of the human race. So is God’s survival because we need Him as our succour in reality. Man and God need each other. Even advanced scientists today see God at the end of their tether and achievement both. 

        The idea that 'I' do everything and all this belongs to 'me,' is the absence of, and the idea that God does all and all belongs to Him, is a sign of vivayka or discrimination and vairaagya or detachment, respectively. To realize that all is God and there is nothing outside Him is vivayka. To treat nothing as mine and all as His, is vairaagya. Even as an experiment if we keep these thoughts active in our mind and dedicate our daily work diligently done as duty to God, we experience, if we are percipient, that God’s grace improves our situation and attitude for us to persevere in the experiment. 

40    Dohaa: Santa kahahin asa neeti Prabhu sruti puraana muni gaava: 
Ho-yi na bimala bibayka ura guru sana ki-yayn duraava:: BK 45

40.     Honouring Yaajnavalkya as his guru, Bharadwaaja said, "Men of divine vision, the Vedas, the Puranas and sages declare a maxim. A disciple cannot gain knowledge if he hides his doubts from his guru."

        Doubt is the natural preliminary for inquiry. Therefore we should accept a guru after very carefully testing him. Testing does not hurt a true guru. (See 157, 206) Thereafter, we should not hold back questions, which agitate our mind and deprive us of peace. We should learn by humble inquiry, by experiments with what we learn, by unswerving faith and by perseverance. (See Geetaa 4:34) Incidentally, a guru is a combination of a psychologist, a psychiatrist, a counsellor and a benefactor and all selflessly. (A Proverb) 

41    Dohaa:   Brahma jo vyaapaka biraja aja, akala aneeha abhayda: 
So ki dayha dhari ho-yi nara, jaahi na jaanata bayda:: Bk50 
Chaupaayi:  Bisnu jo sura-hita nara-tanu-dhaaree: so-u sarabagya jathaa Tripuraaree:: 
Khoja-yi so ki agya iva naaree: jnaana-dhaama Shreepati asuraaree:: Bk51

41.       Satee asked Shiva, "Brahman is all pervading, is pure, is never born, has no qualities, has no desires and can never be fragmented. The Vedas could not know Him. Can the same Brahman assume a human form? Vishnu, a name of Brahman in Its aspect with form, assumed a human form for the good of the gods and was as all knowing as Shiva. Vishnu was Lakshmee's consort, the fount of Knowledge and the destroyer of Evil. How could He, in His Incarnation as Shree Raama, be ignorantly searching for his consort?" (See 241[36]) 

        On seeing Shree Raama searching for Seetaa, Shiva had earlier addressed Him as Satchidaananda. Shiva did obeisance to Him and happily meditated upon Him. Satee saw all this. She doubted if the formless Brahman could appear in a human body. All that is said about Brahman appeared impossible for a man. Vishnu did become incarnate. Even He could not be Shree Raama. She accepted Shiva's explanation that Shree Raama was Brahman in person. Her doubt about his being God Almighty Vishnu in a human form remained. Shiva permitted Satee to test if Shree Raama was God Almighty Vishnu. 

       Satee's doubt whether God could take a human form, agitates some minds till today. (See 21, 65 [2-15, 18, 20], 411) The effort to resolve this doubt led to the revelation of Vedanta. (See 241) Swami Ramakrishna calls Brahman, the Nitya or the formless Absolute, and Shree Raama, the Leelaa or the Relative in a form. (RK 523) The Swami experienced the Absolute with the help of the Relative in goddess Kaalee. In other words, the Swami attained the formless aspect of God through His form. (See 61

42    Chaupaayi:   Ho-yihi so-yi jo Raama rachi raakhaa: ko kari taraka barrhaava-yi saakhaa:: Bk52

42.     On Satee's departure to test if Shree Raama was Almighty God Vishnu, Shiva had a premonition and surrendered himself to Shree Raama with these words, "Everything happens as Shree Raama wills. What is the sense in prolonging arguments on this subject?"

[1]     What does God's will mean? God has not revealed His will or secret and maya prevents our knowing it. (See 147-148) By our percipient observation and repetitive experience, we can only make a surmise about it. It is God's will that we cannot escape from karma or activity for a moment and from going through the form of its consequence, as for example a fall. But the impact of this consequence on us, that is the grievousness of the injury from this fall, is subject to God's grace, which we can invoke for our relief. (See 185[1-8, 10. 11. 23-25], 261) We experience God's will in His response to us, in the manner of our concept about and yearning for Him. (See 34, 101) God provides us repeated opportunities to redeem ourselves in our life; if we fail, God gives us as many lives as we need to reach Him. God appears by His will on the earth in human form from time to time to reciprocate our love for Him in the manner we can understand it because God is a reality for the believer to experience. (See 73)

[2]     For our relief, God's will provides us the facility of His name to remember and that of repentance followed by surrender to Him and avoiding sin thereafter.  Another facility is our inability to commit a punishable sin by the mind. (See 33, 325-326, 428) These facilities help us to be free from suffering. (See 415

        For availing of all the above facilities God has given us a mind for our use till our end that is free from the constraints of any sacred book or revelation and even the word of God conveyed directly to us. If the last was final, we should have been denied the use of our mind thereafter by nature and not by any injunctions in any holy book. (See Geetaa 18:63) Therefore to understand the mind for its best use becomes our duty to ourselves

[3]     It is also God's will that He enabled the ancient Indian sages to purify their minds and develop rarefied intellects to make the greatest discovery that man ever made by observation and experience. The discovery was that our reality, which is our jeevaatmaa or human soul, is one with the reality of God in His substance, nature, power and capacity, and that man alone is gifted with the facility of the mind to make use of this discovery for the benefit of man. This oneness with God is true and has practical meaning for us only if by living in it, we become free of fear and misery on one hand and capable of achieving any selfless noble purpose for the good of all on the other. It is experienced that this oneness bestows unasked on us continual bliss and unlimited power. Sages experienced  that the more pure their minds were the more power they received step by step because they became nearly one with our jeevaatmaa. This power is beyond our physical and mental power on which we rely and often feel proud of our achievement in material sciences. Mahatma Gandhi received this power because he lived by Sanaatana principles. For ancient Indian sages, this discovery made physical sciences secondary for securing man's continual happiness. This divine power that man holds within himself is beyond any that any other being in the creation has. This power is for doing the impossible as long as it is selfless and benevolent for all. It becomes available to us when we make God our objective of life by living in our reality of divinity. For this living, we have to align our intellect with our inmost Self or God. 

[4]     For this alignment, we have to understand how our mind works and how to control it. We should understand that the five senses are inert. What they perceive has no intrinsic quality. It is the intelligence in us, which gives power to senses and our six passions give quality to perceived objects. The mind performs four functions. First. Our mind, or mana, receives from the five senses impulses or information from the outside, transmits them to the intellect for it to direct limbs for action. For this function it is called the mind. Second. When it discriminates between right and wrong and the real and unreal, it is called the intellect or bud-dhi. Third. When it stores memories of experiences to help the intellect to draw upon to discriminate, and direct the organs in the body to function, it is consciousness or Chit-ta. Fourth. It is the ‘I’ which decides to receive or not receive impulses or respond to them, to discriminate, to make the mind function, or not. This 'I' in our mind is called ego or ahamkaara. It is not pride. The mind performing these four functions is called antahkarana, or the subtle body within our physical body. (See 450[10]) In its first role, the mind is merely a channel or the birthplace of desires prompted by our six passions. The second role of the mind as the intellect is to synthesize the information from observation and experience which the mind receives to make it knowledge, to analyze knowledge, to discriminate between right and wrong for our use and, lastly, to discriminate between the worthwhile and worthless desires. Compassion, which is service of the needy gives virtue to intellect to make it common sense, which transcends intellect. Common sense is the harmony of the intellect and the heart, neither dominating the other. Intellect prevents the heart from becoming sentimental and the heart prevents the intellect from becoming callous. When unrestrained, both harm their owner. Thus common sense is not always intellect or pure reason. Animals apparently do not have this complex mental set up or antahkarana. 

[5]    In addition to our five senses and mind, God's will provides us with six passions, namely, desire, including lust, anger, greed, the feeling of 'I' and 'mine,' which is attachment and pride and envy. The minimum and controlled use of passions is necessary for our survival. That is why everyone is gifted with this essential facility of six passions. We allow their uncontrolled power at our peril. We strengthen ourselves by making use of them by their sublimation. For example, we channel our desire to help others, our anger to direct against injustice and misery, our greed for increased capacity for charity and for selfless service, our attachment to noble pursuits, our 'I' or ego for humility essential for acquisition of knowledge and true leadership and our envy for emulating the noble. In this way we make passions our friends to help us achieve the worthwhile. This is how man has progressed to reach where he is today. 

[6]     We find that the senses are more powerful than the body or muscle power. The mind is more than the senses. The intellect is more than the mind. The consciousness of 'I' as the doer is more than the intellect. And, the inmost Self or the soul is more powerful than the 'I.' (See Geetaa 3:42) From the physical to mental and then spiritual, the deeper we go within, the more powerful we become to control and master our equipment, ourselves, situations and people for the good of all. This power from our inmost Self diminishes with each step outward till we reach the body. This is because with our uncontrolled mind, senses and organs, we are naturally attracted to sensuous and material enjoyment of and through our body, sometimes in the manner worse than that of a beast. Our discriminating mind alerts us to the power of senses and passions and pulls us away from worldly attractions to develop detachment. Detachment is the first step to align our intellect with our inmost Self or jeevaatmaa

        Thus when we indiscriminately follow our senses and passions we become an animal. When we follow the mind with discrimination, we become human. When we follow the intellect with compassion, we become selfless and less worldly. When we follow our   jeevaatmaa we become divine. We should ensure that our soul or jeevaatmaa should hold sway over all by their alignment with the jeevaatmaa. This realization makes us experience the existence of power within us. Our thinking that our reality is our body and brain and that we are separate from God keeps our 'I' and intellect away from and unaligned with our jeevaatmaa and makes us powerless, weak and subject to misery and disease. The alignment with our reality in jeevaatmaa with faith in its benefit to us of a powerful but benevolent mind and of freedom from need, disease and fear, is practical Indian philosophy or the science of living for us, for which the Shree Raamacharita Maanasa provides us tips. 

[7]     This alignment of our intellect with our jeevaatmaa to give us increasing control over our mind is sustained by our change in attitude towards everything around and within us. This change needs that we get convinced that God is a reality for us, is all and He does all, and it is better to become His instrument than to seek happiness independent of Him. We resolve to eschew errors by being alert to the working of six passions in us that cause all errors. (See Geetaa 9:30) We live in righteousness, rectitude, compassion and benevolence hurting none and helping all. In our mind we are clear that the world is unreal but we deal with it as a reality. We give a high purpose to our life by mentally treating all as God and one with us in reality and so motivating all our thought, word and deed by love. We treat every act as duty dedicated to God and surrender for His choice for us the fruit of our labour. This fruit is inherent in the act and so, is our inalienable right. For getting the strength for this manner of living, we make secure our link to God by remembering Him as often as we can and mentally praying to Him for help. We cannot restrict God to respond only to a regime of physical manner of prayers, disciplines, meditation and austerities. He can and does take cognizance of other method that we are capable of thinking and following to reach Him because He loves all. 

[8]      We experience that our benevolence or charity creates greater capacity and opportunities for it. For example, selfless social workers are seldom in dire need or unhealthy; ill health, if there is any, never obstructs their work. There is always plenty of work for them and both energy and time for it. Often we see almost insuperable tasks performed by seemingly incapable people. This is how this cosmic power arises from within us by our introspection and benevolence. 

[9]     The mind is compared to a bundle of desires as a piece of cloth is of threads. If we unravel the threads the cloth disappears. If there is no desire, the mind disappears. Desire produces thoughts and vice versa. Senses cannot do anything by themselves. When there is no desire, there is no mind and no need for alertness for or control of passions. All acts, however, arise from desires for a specific result or fruit. To minimize desires, we reject the non-benevolent or ignoble one. We dedicate noble desires, acts in their pursuit and their result or fruit to God. Our mind is thus free from desires and purified to serve the intellect aligned with the Self. Another way to purify the mind is to motivate all our thought, word and action by love for all and hurt for none. A purified mind is fit for alignment with our inmost self or jeevaatmaa. Our conscience is more a matter of our heart where love should prevail over the intellect. A polluted mind, however, can overwhelm our conscience to misguide us. (See 318, 252

[10]     Our antahkarana has tremendous power both for good and evil. Our mind, by itself, is powerless and is a mere channel for stimuli and response. The intellect empowers it. When the intellect is not aligned with our inmost self, it empowers the mind for evil. Our aligned intellect empowers the mind for doing good. The mind is the instrument for all human achievement and, when uncontrolled, for mass destruction. (See Geetaa 6:5-6) We rejuvenate our mind by purposeful or healthy inquisitiveness and also by introspection, contemplation and meditation. A rejuvenated mind strengthens us.

[11]     It is our observable 'I,' which enjoys or suffers and makes life wretched by its anxiety for specific fruit of our diligent work for our livelihood and progress. Once we understand that our attachment to specific fruit is the cause of our anxiety, strain and fear, we entrust that fruit to God's better choice for us. This entrusting frees us from all strains, which cause inefficiency and our ill health. It simultaneously makes our free mind listen to our intellect. This entrusting to God is a method for alignment. 

        God mercifully allowed the mind to raise only one desire at a time. The 'I' can make the intellect substitute each desire motivated by a selfish passion by another motivated by love for all. This is another way to strengthen alignment. 

        To recollect the law of karma and thereby not to bear any grievance, grudge, anger or hate against an offender prevents the pollution of our mind and makes it aligned to our aatmaa

        Keeping the purified mind filled with prayers and benevolent thoughts and intents for all makes it fit for alignment. Our alignment or link to God itself purifies the mind. When we think of God we think twice before we take any action not based on hurt none and help all. Our link with God secures for the mind that continual happiness, which is within us and not in objects outside us. This alignment makes us unconsciously follow almost all paths to reach God. 

        The best path, which Shiva recommends for this alignment is one-sided love for God in His personal aspect. (See 360, 444

[12]     The above way to a noble objective needs the solitude of a room or of the night to think for, talk with and critically examine ourselves, followed by prayers to God for guidance and freedom from worry and from fear. It needs faith and determination to form an incessant link to God through prayers and perseverance. (See Geetaa 2:58-59, 6:35) Once on this noble way, God speeds our advance. (See 19, 34, 233) Slowly we observe our desires subdued, our noble and selfless thoughts materializing, our health improving, our situation becoming more favourable and ceasing to be beyond our control and our mind becoming calm day by day. We did not experience all this before we took this path. For spreading happiness to those we can reach, we do not try to gain any of the psychic powers mentioned in 240 [11-16, 22]. Through our alignment with our inmost Self, we do get without seeking whatever power is necessary for our selfless and benign purpose and pursuits of the highest order. (See 107) All along, we have to remember that if our objective becomes securing even one psychic power from the cosmos, it takes us away from God. If God becomes our objective, we get all the powers without much labour for our selfless use only which is possible only in society and service for it. For sustaining our selflessness, we have always to keep God in our mind as the doer of all our deeds. By living in Sanaatana Dharma every step of his life, Mahatma Gandhi was a living example of a mind aligned with his aatmaa. It gave him unasked that power which performed the miracle of India’s independence and that of preventing single handed the massacre of almost a million on the eastern front of India in its Partition in 1947 which 60,000 armed personnel could not prevent on the western front. 

[13]     Sometimes even after our surrender of our ‘I’ and all to God, we slip into thinking that we are independent in doing our deeds. This is caused by maya through the power of the passion 'I' and 'mine.' (See 66, 239) By knowing this possibility, we always treat our free will as one with God's will as Lakshmana did. We give God the power of attorney as Swami Ramakrishna calls this surrender of our free will to God. This is bud-dhiyoga. It is universally believed that God nourishes those who surrender to Him without any trace of the 'I' as a doer or of doubt in their mind in His reality and faith in that reality for our succour and intimate relationship with Him. 

[14]     Tulaseedaasa shows Shree Raama telling us the practical methodology to achieve the objective of alignment for receiving an empowered mind to do the apparently impossible. We should develop faith based on conviction. (See 2) We should have a purified mind. (See 318) Impurities are given in 272 and 242. We may not succeed in mastering them by confrontation. (See 300) So, we follow Shree Raama's advice in 259

[15]     Only the foolish treat the precept in this couplet as an excuse for pessimism. God's will has provided us with all the means for dynamic activity full of hope to achieve any noble height. The correct understanding of God's will helps the wise use of the means for securing bliss for ourselves through sowing it for those around us. By having faith in the law of karma and God as being our loving mother always running to us for our succour if we take to His path, we may not find the above methods for our alignment beyond us. If difficult, we can repeat God's name, keeping His form in our heart or remember Him somehow and motivate all our acts by love all and hurt none, with faith in Him to see us through. (See 33) It is God's will to respond to our unexpressed intent and desires, improve us and give us the best. (See 205) (A Lesson and a Proverb) 

43    Dohaa:   Puni puni hrida-ya bichaaru kari dhari Seetaa kara roopa: 
Aagai ho-yi chali pantha tayhi jayhi aavata nara-bhoopa:: Bk52 
Chaupaayi:   Jori paani Prabhu keenha pranaamu: pitaa-samayta leenha nija naamu::
Kahay-u bahori kahaan Vrishakaytu: bipin akayli phira-hu kayhi haytu:: Bk53

43.     After anxious deliberation, Satee assumed Seetaa's form. She appeared a bit ahead in Shree Raama's path. Respectfully greeting Satee, he announced his father's and his own name. He asked her where Shiva was and why she was wandering alone in the forest. 

        Satee took Shiva's permission to test if Shree Raama was God. By performing a miracle He removed her doubt. (See (38) in the Story) 

44    Chaupaayi:     Hari-ich-chhaa bhaavee balawaanaa: hrida-ya bichaarata Sambhu sujaanaa:: Bk56

44.     Shiva was all knowing. He thought that, after all, Hari's own will was supremely powerful. 

       Returning and out of fear, Satee did not tell Shiva that she assumed Seetaa's form for testing Shree Raama. Reading her mind, Shiva's reaction here shows that none can alter God's will. He is greater than Shiva, the Indian trinity of gods and all gods and deities. Fate determined by God is undone only by Him. Secondly, whatever God does, its cause is not known even to Shiva. (See 147

45    Chaupaayi:     Nahin ko-u asa janamaa jaga maaheen: prabhutaa paa-yi jaahi mada naaheen:: Bk60

45.    Narrating Shiva and Satee's story to Bharadwaaja, Yaajnavalkya mentioned the proverb, "No one was ever born on the earth who was not intoxicated with pride on getting power and authority."

       The deep Sanaatana wisdom in this couplet that is proverbial till today is that authority unleashes the passion, pride. This passion deprives one of discrimination or vivayka. This passion overwhelms those with the power of authority, for example rulers, the executive and the legislators, and causes all misery among the subjects of authority. This people living in the traditional way enough vivayka to see and destroyed the root of corruption in politicians by destroying absolute power of any politicians or party in three elections in nineties. The crust of corruption of half a century will take some time to wear away. 

        The intoxication of pride, as distinct from mere pride, comprises belittling the meritorious. 

        The traditional wisdom in this couplet caused Guha, the King of Nishaada tribe and Lakshmana both, to misunderstand Bharata. They thought that becoming King and finding Shree Raama alone in the forest Bharata was advancing to attack him. (See 176) Lakshmana said to Shree Raama, 

45A    Chaupaayi:   Bharatahi dosha day-i ko jaa-yay: jaga bauraa-i raajapada paa-yay:: Ak228

       "Why blame Bharata? Everybody loses his head on gaining a throne." But Shree Raama replied to Laksmana: 

45B    Dohaa:   Bharatahi ho-yi na raaja-madu, Bidhi-Hari-Hara pada paa-yi:: Ak231

       "Bharata is not intoxicated with kingship even if he becomes equal to Brahmaa, Vishnu or Shiva," the Indian trinity of gods. 

        Three points are worth noting. Bharata was Lakshmana's brother, born through the common gift of the fire god, yet he did not know Bharata's mind. (See (93-95) in the Story and 389) The mental depth, spiritual height and the level of one's devotion are not known either to the devotee or to another. Only God knows it because it is a relationship with Him. Next, it is often wisdom to check our view with one that we trust lest we may be in error under the power of our passions. Here, Lakshmana was under the passion of attachment to Shree Raama. He was however free from the ego of his worldly wisdom and was humble to be able to submit his view to Shree Raama. His desire to communicate with Shree Raama restored his normal relations with his sibling. (See 174) Lastly, Shree Raama protected Bharata, as His devotee, from maya, which causes pride of power. (See 275, 439) (A Proverb) 

46    Chaupaayi:   Jadapi mitra-prabhu-pitu-guru gayhaa: jaa-yi-yay binu bolayhu na sandayhaa:: 
Tadapi birodha maana janha ko-yee: tahaan ga-yay kalyaana na ho-yee:: Bk62

46. Shiva advised Satee, "One may undoubtedly go uninvited to the house of one's friend, master, father or guru. But it does one no good to visit a place where there is a feeling of enmity."

Not listening to this advice resulted in Satee giving up her life at her father's house. (See (38 - 46) in the Story) The lesson is, we should keep away from the inimical. This shows our control over our ego of courage and the desire to demonstrate it and avoids violence. If duty demands our facing the inimical, we should not shirk it. (A Lesson in Conduct)

47    Dohaa:    Kaha muneesa Himavanta sunu jo Bidhi likhaa lilaara: 
Dayva danuja nara naaga muni ko-u na mayttanihaara:: Bk68

47. Naarada studied Paarvatee's palm. He told Himavanta, her father, "The fate written by Brahmaa cannot be erased by a deity, a demon, a human being, an inhabitant of the nether world or a sage."

Four bits of information can be surmised from the astrological birth chart, or the palm or other signs of a person. This person can however earn God's grace, which alters his future beyond prediction. Astrology and forecasting the future are not wholly scientific in the modern sense. For a correct forecast, they rely on the intuition of a purified mind. (See 50

First are the consequences of the deeds of all our past lives, which we may bear, in the present life. We have no control over their form. They comprise our physical and mental capacity and good or bad family and circums- tances. All these form the facilities for our use. We should not waste time and energy in fighting these, which we cannot change. For our fulfilment, we make the best use of what we have by accepting them as facilities or challenges for our advancement. We do not withdraw or try to escape from them or from the world to become a recluse. 

Unless we replenish our present good fortune, which we earned in our past, it may suddenly be exhausted to start our misfortune. If unfortunate, we need relief. There is one method for both, replenishment of good, and relief from bad fortune. It is the surrender of our past and of our-selves to God. We should now onwards eschew error, motivate our deeds by compassion for all, particularly as our service of the needy, and always pray for God's grace for wisdom and strength to persevere. (See 185[2, 8, 15, 16, 19, 24], 259 and Geetaa 9:30

Second are the impressions and memories formed by our past and present karma or deeds. They form our present tendencies, intuition or our nature, which is superimposed upon our divine nature. (See 242) The complex of the two natures distinguishes each individual from others. This distinguishing nature can be astrologically surmised. 

Third are the deeds, which we perform in our present life. 

Fourth are the consequences of deeds of the present life, which are borne in this life itself. The greater the sin the faster is its retribution. (See 316)  Some consequences of our past deeds are postponed for bearing in future lives. It is doubtful if consequences in future lives can be surmised by a fortune-teller without divine vision. 

Naarada says that none else can save us from our fate. We alone can try and change our fate by our repentance and prayer as shown in 50 and 72. God's grace alters our fate because God is supreme in the matter. He administers His laws, including that of karma. (See 185[2, 8, 15, 16, 19, 24)

48    Chaupaayi:    Samaratha kanha nahin dosha Gosaa-yeen: ravi paavaka surasari kee naa-yeen:: Bk69

48. Naarada told Himavanta, Paarvatee's father, "No one finds faults in the powerful, for example, Vishnu (Gosaayeen), the Sun, the fire and the sacred river Gangaa. 

Among others, these four entities have their faults. 1. Vishnu rests on the coils of a poisonous snake Shayshanaaga. 2. The sun dries up both good and bad liquids. 3. Fire destroys both the good and bad things. 4. The sacred and purifying river Gangaa receives filth from its banks. (MP) 

For the good of man, these four powerful entities convert their faults into or overwhelm them with virtues. Vishnu saves man from the poisonous attractions of the world.  The sun creates rain and ripens the harvest. The heat of fire prepares food and medicines. Gangaa sanctifies man. These entities are not decried because they do substantial public good. Similarly, society tolerates human follies, which are harmless to others, if they are overwhelmed by deeds for public good. (See 22) God makes no one wholly good or wholly bad. The couplet reminds us to look for merit in one before condemning one wholly for some fault. 

Naarada described four faults in Shiva. His ornaments were snakes. He drank intoxicants and poison. His third eye was full of fire. His attire was unclean. He smeared on his body the ash of cremated bodies. To the sacred Gangaa flowing from the heavens to the earth, Shiva gave Gangaa some rest on his head in Gangaa’s journey. Tulaseedaasa gives here four similes to match the four faults associated with Shiva. (MP) (A Proverb) 

49    Chaupaayi:   Surasari-jala-krita baaruni jaanaa: kabahun na santa karahin tayhi paanaa:: 
Surasari milay so paavana jaisayn: Eesa aneesahi antaru taisayn:: Bk70

49. Naarada continued, "A holy person never touches wine even if it is made from the sacred Gangaa water. If that wine is put back into Gangaa, the water of the wine is sanctified. In the same way the human being is different from God."

In his novel style, Tulaseedaasa brings out two concepts of Vedanta. (See 241) The first is that the reality of the human being (the jeevaatmaa or the human soul) and God (the Great Soul) is one. The second is that the two appear separate because our jeevaatmaa, pure as always, is covered by the pollution sticking to it in the form of our subtle and causal bodies. These bodies comprise our unfulfilled desires, attachments to worldly attractions and the ego of the observable 'I' as the doer of our deeds. (See 318, 400, 450[10]) 

Wine has two parts, Gangaa water and its impurity in fermented grape juice. The impurity does not change the substance of water as hydrogen and oxygen. The pollution sticks to water as dirt sticks to the human body or an odour pervades the air. When that wine, that is, water and its impurity, is put back into Gangaa, this union with Gangaa destroys the impurity. It is the nature or dharma of Gangaa to destroy impurities. Rid of its impurity, the water of the wine regains its oneness with the sacred Gangaa water. 

Our polluted subtle and causal bodies stick as dirt on our soul. This dirt does not alter the purity of our soul. The simile is unique. Gangaa water in the wine is compared to our soul, the ferment in the water to make it wine to subtle and causal bodies, wine to us, and Gangaa to the Great Soul. With God's grace, when prompted by someone, or an event or by something on our own, we recollect ourselves, surrender to or lean upon God, we recollect our oneness with Him. (See Geetaa 2:51, 9:30, 10:9-11, 11:55, 18:55 and Chap. 12) God fulfils all our noble intents such as securing a purified mind, which is one with our pure jeevaatmaa. In other words, the wine has been poured back into Gangaa. When we lean on God, He purifies us to help us regain our oneness with Him. (See 19, 183) For a way to lean upon God. (see 33, 42[3, 6-13] and 259

50    Chaupaayi:     Jaun tapu kara-yi kumaari tumhaaree: bhaavi-u maytti sakahin Tripuraaree:: Bk70

50. Naarada told Paarvatee's father Himavanta, "If she observes austerities to secure Shiva then he can alter her fate."

Fate is a mixed bag of our desires, attachment to our past deeds and their consequences for bearing in this and or in future lives. (See 47) The Book prescribes these remedies, by almost any of which all of us can free ourselves from our bag of unpleasant fate. The remedies need a strong faith in God as a loving mother. (See 275) (1) To repeat Shree Raama's name (See 33, 72, 426) (2) To motivate all our thought, word and deed by love and compassion for all and hurt for none. (See 259) To perform correct acts after their dedication to Shree Raama. (See 241[18], 265, 400) (3) To develop devotion to Shree Raama. (See 150-168) (4) To follow the path of Knowledge. (See 241[23]) (5) To surrender our past and everything that we possess or do and also ourselves to Shree Raama. (See 318, 325-326) (6) To serve Shree Raama (See 444) (7) To read Raamaayana with reverential faith and understand its message for daily practice. (See 461-462

If fate was supreme, neither could repentance followed by correct conduct thereafter and prayers to God secure relief for us nor was God or any religion necessary for us. (See 165, 185[2, 8] and Geetaa 9:30) God helps us by destroying our attachment to our past karma by thought, word or deed and thereby the adverse impact upon us of their present consequences. This is how He changes our fate to give us relief from the law of karma. God does not destroy any past or present karma. A fall from a moving vehicle is the inescapable shape of consequence. But God is supreme in giving us a grievous or no injury. (See 72) All the above remedies rest on the faith that God loves us as a mother to give us relief. This faith helps the concentration of our body, mind and senses, or yoga or austerity, upon our objective of bliss and God. 

50A    Chaupaayi:   Mantra-mahaa-mani bisha-ya-bayaala kay: mayttata katthina ku-anka bhaala kay:: Bk32

Tulaseedaasa says, "Engrossment in Shree Raama's virtues displayed in his life story is a mantra, the most precious jewel. It destroys the poisonous snake of worldly attachment and wipes out our misfor-tunes." If we remember His name, form, glory or abode and pray to Him, He alters our fate. (See 49, 325 and Geetaa 4:11, 9:22

We cannot know either what is written in our fate or how much of it is wiped out by our effort, which earned God's grace. We are advised that, ‘God's grace can destroy the effects of past karma or modify its rigour. Never doubt that Grace is like the morphine, the pain is not felt though you go through it. If you earn the anugraha or grace of the Lord, no astrological combination of planets (grahas) can harm you.’ (BS 1 196; 4 120; 2 28, 126) (Parentheses Author's) 

This is because God loves us as our mother and never hurts us. The past cannot be altered. Nothing in the coming events in the universe is unalterable. Our fate coming to us the next moment onwards is not beyond the universe and is therefore alterable. Man's fate is God's will. God Himself can alter it. (See 185[2, 8, 16, 24], 261

The context of the instant couplet refers to Paarvatee. Her fate is written not by God but by Brahmaa, the god entrusted with bringing about the creation and the writing of the fate of creatures. So, Shiva has the power to alter the impact of this fate. Moreover, Shiva is known to be easily pleased. To pray to him is to get a fast response. 

51    Chaupaayi:   Jaba tayn Satee jaa-yi tanu tyaagaa: taba tayn Siva mana bhaya-u biraagaa:: 
Dohaa: Chidaananda sukhadhaama Siva, bigata-moha-mada-kaama: 
Bicharahin mahi dhari hrida-ya Hari, sakala loka abhiraama:: Bk75

51. Narrating Shiva and Paarvatee's story to Bharadwaaja, Yaajnavalkya said, "After Satee immolated her body, Shiva developed non-attachment to his surround-ings. Shiva is consciousness and bliss, the very nature of Brahman. He is beyond any attachment, pride and desire. He gives happiness to the three worlds. He fixed his mind on Vishnu (Brahman in person), and wandered about on the earth."

Brahman or His manifested form in Shree Raama, is the controller of maya. Maya creates attachment to the world to cause ignorance. Even the Indian trinity of gods became a victim of mayaic attachment. (See 406) Shiva himself recalled later the effect of maya on him. 

51A    Chaupaayi: Taba ati socha bha-ya-u mana moray: dukhi bha-ya-un biyoga priya toray:: Uk56

Shiva said to Paarvatee, "I greatly suffered from your separation when, as Satee, you immolated yourself." (See (51) in the Story) The performance of her duties to her husband makes a wife his devotee. (See 220) In this way Satee was the single-minded devotee of her Lord Shiva. 

51B    Chaupaayi: Karayhu sadaa Sankara-pada-poojaa: naari-dharama pati dayva na doojaa:: Bk102

Her mother told Paarvatee, "Always worship the feet of your Lord Shiva. A woman's one dharma is that she has no God other than her husband." This sacred injunction also makes Satee Shiva's devotee. (See 216) Scriptures demand the husband's chastity to the wife. Shree Raama demonstrated it. 

Happiness in marriage rests upon oneness of spouses. Maximum adjustment for this oneness is often easier for a woman than for a man. That is why to facilitate that adjustment or merging is emphasized as her dharma. Man’s lust denies chaste love and security to spouse to obstruct this oneness that demands care and sacrifice for her. Man’s lust destroys marriage, nourishes prostitution of woman and sometimes man’s destruction. It is always an obstruction to man’s power, prosperity and fame. (See 222, 312

Satee, a devotee, immolated her body in the sacrificial ceremony where she could not bear disrespect to her husband and Lord. (See 345) Her Lord, Shiva, was pained by his devotee's sacrifice. His non-attachment to his surroundings, caused by this pain, was the proof of the love of a personal God, Shiva, for His devotees. The gods in the Indian trinity know when maya affects them and why. Shiva knew his attachment to Satee was maya and found refuge in God's name. (See 67,407) Unlike gods, it is difficult for us to recognize maya's insidious working within us through the six passions, particularly pride or our 'I.' So, unlike Shiva, we do not seek protection from maya, which is available to us as much as it was to Shiva. (See 272[1-10, 13, 14], 275

52    Chaupaayi:   Guru kay bachana prateeti na jayhee: sapanayhu sugama na sukha sidhi tayhee:: Bk80 

52. Paarvatee said to the seven sages. "The disciple who does not trust his guru's words does not get peace and happiness even in his dream."

A guru can remove a disciple's doubts and fears and give him relief in his suffering. (See 157) The doubting disciple does not ask his guru and secure relief. His mind remains agitated and without any peace. The lesson is: when in doubt or in difficulty, inquire and communicate, and not withdraw into a shell. (See 174

53    Dohaa:   Mahaadayva-avaguna bhavana, Bisnu sakala-guna-dhaama: 
Jayhi kara manu rama jaahi sana, tayhi tayhee sana kaama:: Bk80

53. Paarvatee continued, "Maybe Shiva is the home of all faults and Vishnu of all virtues, but one's heart is in what it fancies."

To test Paarvatee's love for Shiva, he sent seven sages to her. They decried Shiva and extolled Vishnu as a better groom for her. Paarvatee's response is sound advice even today. 

Treating Shiva, as her God, Paarvatee was observing austerities. She was praying to Him to secure His love. A man can establish with God any loving relationship he likes. (See 34, 246

Paarvatee shows that we should remain firm in the relationship of mother, father or any other with our deity as the form of Brahman. We should not change our relation-ship or shift from one deity to another as the form of Brahman. Single-minded devotion is called the devotion of a chaste wife to her husband. (See 155) The name and form of God we worship do not matter if we stay with the same for good. Shifting devotion delays growth, as the shifting of a plant. 

Both Shiva and Vishnu are aspects of God. It is ignorance to compare gods and God's own Incarnation in Shree Raama. No one has complete knowledge about both. (See 65[2-15, 18, 20], 411

To devote to one form and respect others' deities also as forms of one's own God is the correct single-minded devotion to God.  

After living in the message from the scriptures in which he believes, a man gains experience of God. Another may experience beyond scriptures. Every experience differs. (See 101) God, not the book gives the experience. A holy book or a guru only helps. God is as one believes in Him. A godly man cannot question another's concept of God (Who creates concepts), the form of his worship (which is immaterial to God in man's direct relationship with Him) and the practices of his society (which are changeable and not religion). So, to respect the concept of God and the form of His worship in others' religions as an aspect of God we worship is Sanaatana Dharma. All paths to or forms of worship of God lead to Him. Sanaatana Dharma prohibits us from trying to change a man's belief about, form of worship of, or his path to God. It is violence. (See 398) Sanaatana Dharma helps all to become firm in their own religion by exemplifying the core of all religions, namely, our oneness with all in God through our conduct of love and peace. (See 464 and Geetaa 7:21) The seven sages tried to change Paarvatee's faith in Shiva. Paarvatee admonished them. (A Proverb) 

54    Chaupaayi:     Tadapi karaba main kaaja tumhaaraa: sruti kaha parama dharama upakaaraa:: Bk84

54. Kaamadayva said to the gods, "I shall do your work because the Vedas declare service for others as the highest dharma." (See Geetaa 3:21-24, 11:55

The gods requested Kaamadayva to wake up Shiva from his blissful meditation. If Kaamadayva annoyed Shiva, Kaamadayva could lose his life. Remembering, however, selfless service of others for the welfare of society as the highest duty and the highest form of devotion to God, Kaamadayva proceeded to do it. (See 386 and Geetaa 5:25, 12:4) He tried to wake up Shiva by overwhelming him with lust. Shiva destroyed him as the god of lust. 

With the destruction of lust in us, love shines forth in its true majestic form. One of the forms of that love is compassion, sympathy and selfless service particularly of the needy around us. (See 259, 360[9, 11, 12], 444) Baba says, ‘If the individual is deluded into believing that he is saving others, then woe be to him; for there is no other at all. All are one; one man's sorrow is everyone's sorrow.’ (BS 3 68) (See 241

55    Chaupaayi:     Naarada kara main kaaha bigaaraa: bhavana mora jinha basata ujaaraa::
Para-ghara-ghaalaka laaja na bheeraa: baanjha ki jaana prasava kee peeraa:: Bk97

55. Paarvatee's mother Mainaa exclaimed in despair, "How have I hurt Naarada that he wished my established home uprooted? He has neither any sense of shame nor fear. How can a barren woman know the pangs of childbirth?"

Shiva's scary apparel and frightful attendants in his marriage party scared Mainaa. If she refused to marry her daughter, Paarvatee, to such an odd bridegroom, she could take it that her established home would be as good as destroyed by the groom's attendants. How could Naarada know the pain of seeing a home uprooted when he never set up a home for himself? Many disturbing incidents resulted from Naarada's discourses. 

55A    Dohaa:     Naarada kara upadaysa suni kahahu basay-u ko gayha:: Bk78

The sages told Paarvatee, "After listening to Naarada's discourse, whose home remained established?" The listeners developed non-attachment to the world and gave up their hearth and home. Sages told Paarvatee not to trust mischievous Naarada. 

Without learning lessons from experience of suffering, one cannot fruitfully advise another in his suffering. This proverb cautions us against inexperienced advisers. (A Proverb) 

56    Chaupaayi:   Ajaa anaadi sakti abinaasini: sadaa Sambhu aradhanga-nivaasini:: Jaga-sambhava-paalana-la-ya-kaarini: nija ich-chhaa leelaa-bapu-dhaarini:: Bk98

56. Naarada explained to Mainaa, Paarvatee's mother, "Paarvatee never takes birth, has no beginning or end and is cosmic power personified for ever. She remains Shiva's inseparable consort and the symbolic half of his body. She creates the universe, sustains it and destroys it. She appears in any form of her choice."

It is Paarvatee's body that takes birth and dies just as a human body does. Her soul does not. It enters and leaves the body. All Shaktis such as Paarvatee, Saraswatee and others incarnate as the active or maya aspect of Brahman by Its will. (See 85

It is believed that every universe has its own gods of the Indian trinity along with their power. Shakti or power is their integral attribute and personified as their consort. (Geetaa 4:11, 7:21-23, 9:23-27) These gods and their power become incarnate by the inspiration, power and grace of Brahman as Paramayshwara. They generally last for the life of their universe. (See 79) In this period we complete many births. Relative to us the gods of the trinity and their Shakti as consorts are immortal. 

Goddess Paarvatee personifies a woman's lifetime married status with one husband. So, she is symbolically the left half of Shiva’s body. This signifies that for a happy married life, the wife merges her identity in her husband’s. For his own protection and survival by being the right half, the husband cares for her as for his own body. The husband’s interests precede her maternal interests. The husband avoids pain to his wife, including that to her maternal bonds, as he avoids pain to his own body. 

57    Chaupaayi:   Kata bidhi srijee naari jaga maaheen: paraadheena sapnayhu sukha naaheen:: Bk102

57. Paarvatee's mother Mainaa said, "Why has Brahmaa created woman in the world? She can never have happiness even in her dreams because she depends on others?"

At the time of giving away Paarvatee in marriage to Shiva, her mother Mainaa exclaimed these words of anguish before Paarvatee. 

If a husband provided the needs of his wife, there would be no women's liberation movement. When society lived in truth and self-sacrifice the family had its primary role of the proper bringing up of children. Women sustained culture for a self-sufficient, noble and advancing society. The essential element in this was provision for women's security, chaste love, leisure for noble pursuits in spirituality, art, literature and crafts for self-expression to spread joy around them. In their security, women never needed independence and gave immense power to their husbands through their devotion to them as their God. (See 222) Is women's happiness in independence from their husbands or in the couples reverting to their conduct in divine nature of truth and love that gives to, and not demands from the spouse? Love that demands is lust or attachment or an animal passion. It destroys homes that animals do not have. Sanaatana Dharma emphasizes control over, and independence from our six passions. The happiness of love is in the selfless service of the loved one, which is helped by control over passions. (See 360

Incidentally, in the absence of gurus, the illiterate Indian masses retained their grounding in Sanaatana Dharma through innumerable proverbs in local dialects such as this couplet. It reminds us of the need to rely not on people and things around us but on our inmost Self. (See 42[3, 6-13]) (A Proverb) 

58    Chaupaayi:   Siva-pada-kamala jinhahin rati naaheen: Raamahin tay sapnayhun na suhaheen:: 
Binu chhala Bisva-naatha-pada nayhoo: Raama-bhagata kara lach-chhana ayhoo:: 
Siva sama ko Raghupati-brata-dhaaree: binu agha tajee Satee asi naaree:: Bk104

58. Narrating Shiva and Paarvatee's story, Yaajnavalkya said to Bharadwaaja, "Those who had no love for Shiva were not liked by Shree Raama even in His dream. The sign of Shree Raama's devotee was that he had guileless love for Shiva. Who could equal Shiva as Shree Raama’s devotee who gave up his consort as good as Satee for no fault on her part?"

The reason why Shiva gave up Satee was, 

58A    Chhanda:   Siyaa-baysa Satee jo keenha tayhi aparaadha Sankara pariharee:: Bk98

Narrating the story of her past life as Satee to Paarvatee's mother, Mainaa, Naarada said, "Satee assumed Seetaa's form. For this apparent fault Shiva gave up Satee." (See 41-44) Seetaa was Shree Raama's consort, who was Shiva's master. To Shiva it was against his sense of propriety to continue his former relationship with Satee after she assumed the form of Seetaa even for a few moments. (See 411

Shree Raama is shown also to point out that a sign of devotion to him is the seeker's devotion to Shiva. (See 395 and Geetaa 4:11, 7:21-23) Yaajnavalkya is drawing attention here to the precept that aversion to another’s concept or form of God and the manner of his worship is ignorance of the oneness of the only Almighty God that there can be and so is in all His forms, visible or invisible. Any path of devotion to God which divides men who are all children of God is fruitless. (See 155) The moment one is aware that God is literally omnipotent and the personification of love, one realizes that God reciprocates every devotee's love in the manner of his virtuous choice. His religion is immaterial to God. 

59    Dohaa:     Prabhu samaratha saravagya Siva sakala-kalaa-guna-dhaama: 
Joga-jnaana-bairaagya-nidhi pranata-kalapataru naama:: Bk107

59. Paarvatee said to Shiva, "You are the Lord who has all power and knows all. You are the repository of all arts, virtues, meditation, Knowledge and non-attachment. The repetition of your name is the wish fulfilling tree for the seeker of your refuge."

Paarvatee prayed to Shiva first in this manner and then asked him to enlighten her about Shree Raama. A kalpataru is a legendary tree. It fulfils all good and bad wishes affecting the seeker, be he good or bad. The tree is similar to Shiva only in treating all seekers alike. It is believed that the tree can make a person religious minded. It cannot secure him heaven, a vision of God and salvation. Being a guru and a god, Shiva can secure a disciple these boons also. (MP) 

60    Dohaa:    Jo nripa-tana-ya tau Brahma kimi naari-biraha mati bhori: 
Daykhi charita mahimaa sunata bhramati bud-dhi ati mori:: Bk108 
Banda-un pada dhari dharani siru bina-ya kara-un kara jori: 
Baranahu Raghubara-bisada jasu sruti sid-dhaanta nichori::  Bk109

60. Paarvatee asked Shiva, "If Shree Raama was the son of a king, how could he be Brahman? How could he be so distraught on the loss of his consort? What I see of his actions and what I hear of his praise from you confuse my mind. Please describe Shree Raama's glory together with the essence of the Knowledge which has ever been heard or Shrutis, that is, the Vedas." 

Paarvatee thought her doubts would be resolved only after knowing the concepts revealed as the Vedas. Shiva's narration of Shree Raama's story and explaining to her its message, however, satisfied her. This is because the characters in this story reflect in their conduct the practical essence of the Vedas and how to live in it. So, the greatness of the Shree Raamacharita Maanasa or Raamaayana is in presenting the practicable essence of the Vedas. (See 2A, 36) After studying this Book and a little introspection, we notice that almost all of us live to some extent in vivayka, vairaagya and jnaana. The exception is when our passions overwhelm us. When we say no to many desires, which we can afford, it is Vairaagya. When we think about doable or not doable and sift desires, it is Vivayka. When we do not hurt any, and help all, treating them as one with us in our reality, it is jnaana. We need to know a little more about the subject, its value and the ease of its practice for receiving increased power of our mind by the grace of God. 

Vaalmeeki narrated the Raamaayana to Shree Raama’s sons Lava and Kusha in his lifetime. This Raamaayana is said to show the path of action, deeds or works. The later Adhyaatmic Raamaayana attributed to Vedavyaasa, emphasizes the path of devotion but also gave prominence to the path of Knowledge. Tulaseedaasa presented in the Book all paths giving pre-eminence to the path of devotion based on Knowledge. (See 437 and Geetaa 9:2) 

The basic framework of the traditional story is broadly maintained in all Raamaayanas

The importance of the Raamaayana is not in the proof of events in history or archaeology. It is therefore purposeless to fix the date of the earliest Raamaayana or the exact spot of Shree Raama's birth that took place in the Traytaayuga. (See 79) The importance is in the eternal existence of Shree Raama and all Incarnations of God in the devotees experiencing them all over the world till today. The ideal conduct in life of all Incarnations of God is their message. God and His Incarnations do not exist for non-believers. When non-believers need them, they make their benevolent reality felt by them. (See 267[2]) 

61    Chaupaayi:   Prathama so kaarana kahahu bichaaree: nirguna Brahma saguna bapu dhaaree:: Bk110 
Puni Prabhu kahahu Raama-avataaraa: baala-charita puni kahahu udaaraa:: 
Bhagati jnaana bijnaana biraagaa: puni saba baranahu sahita bibhaagaa:: Bk111

61. Paarvatee said to Shiva, "First please tell me why the unmanifested Brahman manifested Itself as Shree Raama? Please narrate His story and of His lovely childhood. Please explain devotion, Knowledge or jnaana, its experience or vijnaana and non-attachment or vairaagya separately."

Paarvatee thought God did not incarnate in human form. On Shiva's explanation, she accepted it. Did Shree Raama demonstrate His being God since his childhood? Thinking that his story might not tell her the means of attaining God, she asked Shiva about each of those means separately. Shiva's narration of Shree Raama's story and its import resolved all her doubts and gave her Knowledge. This shows that if we understand the message of Shree Raama's story, it gives us the essence of practical ancient Indian wisdom that was the secret of India’s world leadership in prosperity for millenniums. 

Some take jnaana to mean wisdom, metaphysical truth or intuitive knowledge and vijnaana as rational, scientific knowledge or intellectual truth. Shankaraachaarya took jnaana as ‘knowledge of the Self and other things acquired from scriptures and teachers’ and vijnaana as the personal experience of the things so taught. (RG 149) Tulaseedaasa takes, jnaana as Knowledge of the Self (Brahman) through the path of rational inquiry and meditation, and vijnaana as the experience of that Knowledge. This experience develops in the jnaanee love for Shree Raama, Who is an embodiment of Brahman. This love enables the jnaanee to continue to enjoy in life the indescribable bliss of jnaana. (See 438

Tulaseedaasa's view was experienced by Swami Ramakrishna. He says, ‘He alone who after reaching the Nitya, the Absolute, can dwell in the Leelaa, the Relative, and again climb from the Leelaa to the Nitya, the Absolute, has ripe knowledge and devotion... It is vijnaana. To know that there is fire in wood is jnaana. But to make a fire with that wood, cook food with that fire, and become healthy and strong from that food is vijnaana.’ (RK 523, 911) 

Incidentally, the English word selfish is easily understood. The similar words self and Self are not easily understood without proper background of the Indian concept under-lying them. The three words are poles apart from the Hindi words of which they are the nearest equivalents, namely, swaarthee, mamatva and jeevaatmaa, respectively. Some ignorant English-educated Indians today therefore assert that Sanaatana Dharma is a selfish religion. So, this Dharma, which led India to world leadership for millenni-ums, does not interest them. They are ignorant that the self (mamatva) or our active ‘I' cannot become the Self (jeevaatmaa) or God without the total destruction of selfishness (swaartha) through selflessness of karmayoga and devotion to God of the Geetaa. They do not know that Sanaatana Dharma is not a selfish religion but stands only on selflessness. As a minimum, this selflessness comprises hurt none and help all treating them as one with us in our reality. 

Shiva's answer to Paarvatee's inquiry comprises for us today practically all that Sanaatana Dharma is about. All the couplets from the Book bearing upon the topics raised by Paarvatee could not be included in this Selection. The representative few that are included, indicate what a vast ocean of practical wisdom Tulaseedaasa compressed into the small mother of pearl of a small lake called the Shree Raamacharita Maanasa. 

62    Chaupaayi:   Banda-un Baalaroopa so-yi Raamoo: saba sidhi sulabha japata jisu naamoo:: 
Mangala bhavana amanagala haaree: drava-u so Dasaratha-ajira-behaare:: Bk112

62. Shiva said to Paarvatee, "I do my obeisance to the infant Shree Raama. The repetition of his name makes easily available all psychic powers. He removes unhappiness and bestows bliss on everybody. As an infant, he played in Dasharatha's courtyard. O Shree Raama! Be kind to me."

Before answering Paarvatee's questions, Shiva visualized Shree Raama as a child playing in Dasharatha's courtyard because Paarvatee had asked for the narrative from Shree Raama's infancy. Shree Raama performed miracles from His childhood to demonstrate His being God. Moreover, Shiva, as His devotee himself, wanted to enjoy Shree Raama's story from His childhood. 

Shree Raama, playing as an infant in their courtyard, delighted Dasharatha and Kaushalyaa's hearts. Shree Raama's devotees also want that delight from that same image in their hearts. Shiva is shown to express that common desire in the second couplet, which makes this a very endearing couplet for Shree Raama's devotees. (For Shree Raama's Devotee) 

63    Chaupaayi:   Dhanya dhanya Giri-raaja-kumaaree: tumha samaana nahin ko-u upakaaree:: 
Poochhay-u Raghupati-kathaa-prasangaa: sakala loka jaga paavani Gangaa:: 
Tumha Ragubeera-charana anuraagee: keenhihu prasna jagata-hita laagee:: Bk112

63. Shiva congratulated Paarvatee saying, "There is no benefactor such as you. You asked me for Shree Raama's story. Listening to it sanctifies all the worlds as the sacred river Gangaa purifies a sinner (when he turns to God Who fulfils all his noble intents such as sincere repentance and purification of his mind). You have devotion to Shree Raama. However, you asked the questions for the benefit of the worlds."

The worlds are the nether lands, the earth and the heavens. Do those in heaven also have sins to wash off? Residents of heaven enjoy the consequences of their meritorious deeds. After exhausting them, they have to come to the earth again to bear the consequences of other deeds or to fulfil their remaining desires. (See 390 and Geetaa 9:21) Heaven or hell is a temporary sojourn in our journey to merge ultimately in, or regain our oneness with our origin, God. There is no perdition or an eternal heaven in Sanaatana Dharma. Some attain God or Self-realization in life and live as karmayogis such as Janaka, Vaalmeeki and Yaajnavalkya, while others do so after a cycle of rebirth. (See Geetaa 9:18) (Shiva's Discourse to Paarvatee Begins) 

64    Chaupaayi:   Jinha Hari-bhagati hrida-ya nahin aanee: jeevata sava samaana tayi praanee:: Bk113

64. Shiva continued, "A man who has no devotion to God is like a live corpse." 

Non-believers in God's glory and those averse to Him often called ungodly, are not necessarily bad persons. (See 211, 344) We become a non-believer when we forget that God is our reality and underlies the life principle in us. When we do our acts remembering Him we become believers. Those who love and live for others, which is the highest form of devotion to God, truly live in God. It matters little if they are not aware of God or His being in them and are not seen as believers or as devotees of God. (See 267) They are as good as any sincere devotees because both live in love, the core of all paths to God. If, however, non-believers are unrighteous in thought, word and deed, along with hypocrite devotees, they are as good as living corpses. A corpse is avoided and burnt by followers of Sanaatana Dharma. By calling a non-devotee a corpse, Tulaseedaasa treats him as a pollution for our thought, word and deed, to be avoided. (See 11, 15

But godly men should meet those averse to God to lead them to the right path. Please see 398 and 464

65    Chaupaayi: Sagunahin agunahin nahin kachhu bhaydaa: gaavahin muni puraana budha baydaa::
Aguna aroopa alakha aja jo-yee: Bhagata-prayma-basa saguna so ho-yee:: 
Jo guna-rahita saguna so-yi kaisay: jalu hima bilaga upal nahin jaisay:: Bk116

65. Shiva continued, "The sages, the learned, the Puranas and the Vedas all say that there is no difference between God without form and attributes and with form and attributes in His Incarnation. God has no attributes, has no form, is not visible and is never born. He is forced by the love of His devotees, to assume a form and attributes. How can a formless being have a form? It is in the same way that shapeless water takes the shape of a hailstone." 

[1] Water has no shape. It takes the shape of its container. Each hailstone however, which is but water, has its individual shape. The formless God similarly takes different shapes in His Incarnations. 

[2] To understand the reality of a human Incarnation of God we have to start from basics. The basic to any religion is its or its followers’ concept of God. In Sanaatana Dharma God is omnipresent, omnipotent and omniscient. Second. God is the only reality that exists and nothing else can exist outside Him as a reality. So, the reality of all entities in the creation is one with God. Third. God is the personification of the limitless love of our mother. Fourth. He creates the appearance of or brings about, or extends as a part of Him what we observe as the creation, preserves and destroys it cyclically through incessant change in the name and form of all objects in it. Lastly, apparently He gives pre-eminence to man in the creation but does not deny to the rest of it the experience of His relationship with it because He is the reality for all. The reality of God taking a human form arises from these basic and minimum concepts about God and is experienced repeatedly. 

[3] It is in his omnipotence and omniscience that He decides to take a human form for His role of personification of love to give a personal experience of it to those yearning for it on the earth. Love was the only relationship He bestowed upon men from their birth for men and with Himself since man's beginning. We all know it, practise and experience it from our birth and enjoy its bliss by motivating all our acts by it in our family. The only universal religion, if there is any, is love. In the instant couplets, the reason for the Incarnation of Shree Raama is in the words ‘forced by the love of His devotees.’ This reason was more important in the three ages other than Kaliyuga. Another role for the Incarnation is to revive men’s faith in God by exemplary living in His message. The destruction of the wicked in the past or their transformation into good because of their large numbers today is an incidental role of an Incarnation of God. 

[4] That God is the only reality or the Truth shows that all in the creation have to come out of Him and are of His substance and nature in its divinity. This is because something cannot come out of nothing or of unreality. Every object manifests this divinity in varying degree. It is as the same flame in a lamp, but visible differently according to the translucence of its walls. In man walls comprise our egotism. It prevents manifestation of our divinity and separates us from God. In the Incarnation, God manifests His Divinity almost fully. In all of us with God's grace, we can make our divinity manifest by the purification of our mind for our continual bliss and for reaching God. Men of purified mind or annihilated egos are found in all religions and among gurus of divine vision. In India they are called ansha avataaras or minor Incarnation of God. 

[5] To experience our oneness with God, He has gifted us with our mind. It observes the objective world. Beyond the senses, however, it experiences the subjective and spiritual world. This world beyond includes the concept of God, gods, goddesses, their world and that of the sentient and insentient, heaven, hell and many worlds and planes of existence to facilitate the upward journey of man. Man being one with God, ancient sages underwent severe disciplines to purify their mind to recall journeys and sojourns of their past lives in these worlds in their effort to attain oneness with God. Our incapacity to repeat the ancient disciplines and feats of memory does not negate the tradition of their discoveries. For example, the concept of rebirth on the earth was a subjective discovery by these sages. Modern research in hypnotic prenatal mental regression proves rebirth on the earth. 

[6] The subjective world is as real as the objective. It is our subjective mind which experiences the limitlessness of God in His capacity to do the impossible, such as His taking a human form, create dinosaurs and make them extinct and birds and animals talking as human beings in Shree Raama's army and then making them extinct. It is well known that ‘Saint Francis could communicate with animals, birds and even flowers.’ (EFS 134) ‘With men things are impossible, but with God all things are possible.’ (Matthew 19:26) Subjective experience cannot be brought about by logic. Logic cannot disprove experience. For those interested, Alain Danielou has discussed one aspect of this subject in his book 'The Gods of India.' 

[7] Our mind is for our experience of God in the manner of our choice and for our use till the end of our life. That is why after giving jnaana and a vision of His cosmic form to Arjuna, Shree Krishna, advised him to think for himself and then act accordingly. (See Geetaa 18:63) Shree Raama also gave the same advice to citizens of Ayodhyaa. This advice safeguards against our treating God's word in a scripture as final. It prevents our becoming a slave of its interpreter to forget that God is its author inasmuch as He revealed its contents. We cannot bind Him by its puny interpretation or by the experience of revelations to one or a number of men. This insistence of Sanaatana Dharma on the use of our mind encourages purposeful and humble inquiry, exchange of thought, gives value to satyasanga and established a respected tradition in India to have debates on mundane and spiritual matters under royal patronage. This right of free discussion led to acceptance of variety of levels and the reach of the mind to eliminate bigotry and to ensure harmony of living in love. In this acceptance, the believer and non-believer in the Incarnation of God both receive His love and experience it in their own ways. This freedom of thought and its expression ensured development of the mind, its best use for achievement of unparalleled prosperity and progress in the sciences of matter and of the spirit. It prevented Sanaatana Dharma from becoming an archaeological ruin. 

[8] The difficulty of the non-believer in an Incarnation can be his inability to understand an intangible reality under-lying the tangible. The difficulty can be to understand the literal concept of omnipotence and omniscience in that the imperceptible God knows best and can also take a human form. That He does appear as an Incarnation on the earth is experienced by believers in their concept of God of their choice because God is a reality for them. For a non-believer in God in human form He does not appear for them and so is not recognized by them. They even deride others’ experience of God in person. The difficulty can be the inability to experience realities free from others' interpretation of revelations in scriptures. For example, Shree Raama and Shree Krishna were not named in the Vedas and so were not real. It can be the inability to experience phenomena beyond imagination. So, one can decide that God can only be imperceptible and intangible. In this, one limits the limitless God to one’s imagination. The difficulty can also be the inability to understand that it is God who creates strange and contradictory concepts about man and the creation and even about Himself and responds to them for His purpose. Since God is the only ever-unchanging reality, in Sanaatana Dharma, an Incarnation is also a manifestation by God in a form in His totality but limited by His form and by the name His followers give Him. 

[9] Some argue that if God can have tangible forms, for example in an Incarnation, He is not the same forever. God, the reality does not change. All His forms in His creation continuously change. Some argue that the Vedas do no mention Shree Raama and Shree Krishna. Accord-ing to the Shree Raamacharita Maanasa the Vedas existed before Shree Raama. (See 438) Moreover, the Vedas record more of conclusions based upon revela-tions, experience and thought than all the names and events leading to conclusions. The concept of an Incarnation of God was transmitted to us from the Vedas through the Upanishads as the Dvaita school of Vedanta, which recognizes an Incarnation of the personal Almighty God Vishnu. (See 241) The description of the visible cosmic purusha (human) form of God in chapter 11 of the Geetaa is taken from the Rigveda and Yajurveda. The lives of Shree Raama and Shree Krishna merely illustrate this concept. The absence of their or any other name in the Vedas does not prove that both Incarnations of God could not exist before or after the Vedas. None of the Incarnations or Messengers of God wrote their biography. Only the spiritually advanced contemporaries of a purified heart recognized them. The learned in scriptures, devoid of compassion, those shackled by tradition, those proud of their spirituality together with the less spiritually advanced and the victims of maya, remained hostile to them. (See 240[3], 298, 438 and Geetaa 9:11) Hostility to incarnations was by their design to distance the unfit and facilitate the deserving to imbibe and thereafter exemplify the message of the Incarnation for others to follow. No incarnation or Messenger of God because of the limitation of his human body, time and space, can ever physically reach the whole world. 

[10] Evolution of the human mind is a fact in which the Incarnation of God has a distinct place. The kindergarten stage of a devotee appears as the worship of the spirit of trees and of natural forces. The doctoral stage appears as belief in the Ultimate Reality as imperceptible God or Brahman and Its Incarnation. The multiplicity of man's concept of the Creator and of man's relationship of the heart with Him is not ignorance. It is by His will. We cannot prove that the cave man had no concept about God or that his concept did not include experience and vision of God in a human form. After all we see levels of intelligence incapable of believing in a loving and merciful God who has no form resembling human form. We cannot prove that God cannot or does not appear for these minds in the manner they can love Him and can feel the response of God’s love. We can also not prove that from the cave man till today, various concepts about God did not give His intimate or personal experience and joy to man. Their joy sustained man before any religion was articulated or any scriptures were written. So, Sanaatana Dharma holds that there cannot be an only or superior religion and respects the multiplicity of concepts, including God taking a human form, which continues to give relief and innocent joy to man over time. God, gods, goddesses and His Incarnation are all forms of God, the only one that there is, and are all seen or experienced in the manner of the choice of the faithful from time to time and by the insentient in the manner we do not know. The inability of the insentient to show their relationship with God or His forms is no different from our inability to show it and its depth and extent within us to others. 

[11] Shree Raama and Shree Krishna were much before recorded history. For our personal experience history is irrelevant. Without archaeological or other scientific evidence, some rationalists and seekers of tangible proof in matters of the heart, spirit and experience, consider Incarnations of God as not facts but as mythology or at best a symbol. So is God Himself by the same logic and test of tangible proof. Some scientific truths are modified from time to time. The final, unchanging and all encompassing truth or reality eludes scientific discovery. Those who cannot imagine the ever-unchanging reality as the Truth nor can see Its manifestation in myriad forms need a tangible proof. A tangible proof for everything remains a fascinating illusion. (See 67) An insular observer laughs at an Indian trying to reach God in heaven through strange rituals. Each method and experience is, however, true for the seeker of God. God Himself gives experience to the seeker to suit his capacity. To the superficial observer even the universal truths in different religions and in the three aspects of Vedanta appear contradictory. (See 241[6]) The Incarnations, gods and goddesses are true to the believer in God in His with form aspect. They are a myth to the believer in God in His aspect without form. Hence is the parable of blind men and the elephant. By touching the ear, the tail, the legs, the trunk, and the torso, each thought of the elephant as a fan, rope, a pillar, a python, a wall, and so on. 

[12] We are warned by Swami Ramakrishna who saw God that ‘The attitude that my religion alone is right and all other religions are false is not good. I see that God Himself has become all these men, images and Shaalagraamas. (Shaalagraama is a stone symbol through which Vishnu, a name for God Almighty, is worshipped.) I see one alone in all these; I do not see two. I only see one.’ (RK 578) (Parentheses Author's) Icon worship is not a sign of ignorance. ‘He who pervades everything including an idol or icon is invoked in it. (See Geetaa 8:22, 9:6) He is approached reverentially by a purified mind anxious to efface itself to the Eternal and the Universal.’ When we see our beloved in a picture, the paper, paint, glass and frame disappear. If we believe otherwise, we can reject the concept of an Incarnation of God and of His pervading the icon. God will still respond to our form of His worship because He is real and for all. (See 101, 186) It is however unwise to reject the value and benefit of faith of the believer in them. The wisdom of his silence in a non-believing society does not negate the truth and joy of the believer's experiences. Amongst others in the West, Saint Joan of Arc heard heavenly sounds, had visions of saints and saw God Himself. Saint Bernadette of Lourdes saw Jesus Christ's mother Mary. The record of such super-normal experiences cannot be complete because it is mutilated. All history is generally a prejudiced record by the powerful or the victor. 

[13 ] Gods and an Incarnation of God are all God's forms but ordinarily invisible except the Incarnation of God on the earth. All forms have assigned tasks with necessary power to perform them by God's power, inspiration and grace. All have a name and a form and so their bodies must come to an end at the end of their task. (See 79 and dohaa 81 of Uttarakaandda of the Book) The difference is that the Incarnations as Brahman in Its totality decides upon Its own time, place, task and the manner of doing it with limitless power of Brahman in Him but limited by His body and its limitations in speech and in the performance of some roles. Gods are, however, assigned a task. Their power is limited for this purpose and exercised to its maximum and not limited by the body and its limitations except when they choose to perform a task by materializing into a body or to give a vision to their devotee. 

[14] The Shree Raamacharita Maanasa does not mention Shree Raama taking any other form but gods and goddesses take forms for their tasks. 

65A    Chaupaayi: Dayva danuja dhari manuja-sareeraa: bipula-beera aa-yay ranadheeraa:: Bk 251

Gods and demons in the form of human beings and powerful warriors have come to Seetaa's marriage. 

65B    Chaupaayi:   Sachee Saaradaa Ramaa Bhavaanee: jay sura-tiya suchi sahaja sa-yaanee:: 
Kapatta-naari-bara-baysha banaa-yee: mileen sakala ranivaasahin jaa-yee:: 
Kara-hin gaana kala mangala-baanee: harasha-bibasa saba kaahu na jaanee:: Bk318

In the guise of beautiful ladies, Shachee, Saraswatee, Ramaa, Paarvatee, consorts of Indra, Brahmaa, Vishnu and Shiva, respectively, and other goddesses of pure and unusually wise nature were singing sweet songs in the palace of Seetaa's mother, in the celebration of Seetaa's marriage. No one recognized them. 

65C    Chaupaayi:     Bidhi Hari Hara disipati dina-raa-oo: jay jaanahin Raghu-beera-subhaa-oo:: 
Kapatta-bipra-bara-baysha banaa-yay: kautuka daykhahin ati sachupaa-yay:: 
Poojay Janaka dayva-sama jaa-nay: di-yay su-aasana, binu pahichaa-nay:: Bk321

Brahmaa, Vishnu, Shiva, the protector gods of the ten directions, the Sun and other gods assumed the form of venerable Brahmins to watch the function. Without recognizing them, Janaka revered them as if they were gods and gave them seats of honour. 

[15] Does not the Incarnation out of Brahman make the latter the lesser for it? Brahman remains the same just as the ocean is neither reduced by evaporation nor increased by rivers flowing into it, nor a flame reduced by lighting lamps nor a teacher's knowledge by imparting it to students. Eesha Upanishad states that the human soul is of the same substance and divinity as the complete Brahman. It is a part of Brahman's totality and is also that totality. Fullness is Brahman's nature. When the Full is taken away from that Full, the Full remains. This is an Upanishadic axiom. Even after parting with Its totality in Its Incarnation in Shree Raama or others, Brahman remains total. In this divine arrangement the mathematical law of the part and the whole does not apply. Scientific laws are limited to man's knowledge through the five senses and imagination. Divinity demonstrates its being beyond both knowledge and imagination by producing daily phenomena beyond the present ken of science. 

[16] The message of God's love through the Incarnation or otherwise spreads by itself because it is the truth in one of its many aspects. Christianity came to Kerala, South India, where Shankaraachaarya, the exponent of Vedanta, was born earlier. Judas Thomas, one of Jesus Christ's twelve apostles, brought Christianity, summed up in Jesus' message, to India before the Gospels were written by Saints Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, and their interpretations given, and before Christianity reached Europe. Jesus Christ's original message was akin to Vedanta. If Christianity, as its name suggests, is confined to what Jesus Christ said, it is difficult to find anything in the four Gospels, which contradicts the basic beliefs of the three Schools of Vedanta. That explains why some Brahmins, the most learned class, became Christians by conviction and not by conquest, coercion or bribe. Christianity, as Jesus Christ’s original message and free from later 'Churchianity' and the rest of the Bible, is flourishing in India for two millenniums and from earlier than even amongst Romans. This is because there is no clash between the core of what Jesus Christ tried to convey and Vedanta. 

[17] Strange it may seem but India received through their followers the message of almost all religions with a large following in the world. The Indians spiritual tradition sheltered people who were persecuted in their homelands. After the destruction of their temple in Jerusalem in 586 BC by Babylonians and in AD 70 by Romans, some of the Jews forcibly exiled or voluntarily reached Kerala, India. On comparing notes among Jews returning to the present Israel, Indian Jews were the only ones who were never persecuted. Fire worshippers escaped from Iran in the eighth century to find a haven in Gujrat, West India. Known as Parsees (from Persia) they live happily in India till today as a distinguished class. The same spiritual tradition made India's soil so religious as to give birth to two religions in the world, Sanaatana Dharma and Buddhism, and two religions with a smaller following, Jainism and Sikhism. 

[18] From his childhood, the Incarnation of God performs ‘divine’ miracles necessary for His task."Bhagwaana has seven chief characteristics: aishvarya (splendour), keerti (prosperity), jnaana (wisdom), vairaagya (non-attachment), srishtti (creation), sthiti (preservation) and laya (destruction). Whoever has these seven, you can consider as having Divinity in Him. These seven are the unfailing characteristics of avataaras. (BS 1 191) Western specialists published in recent years an account, which was properly investigated for accuracy, of an Incarnation of God living in India today. Observed as performing benign miracles continuously from His closely observed childhood and life, He recreated matter disintegrated over thousands of years, healed the incurables and raised a dead man. He demonstrates divinity to assure us that all of us have the same power but we are neither aware of it, nor sometimes believe that we have it, nor try to purify minds to be able to use our divinity for public good even to a small extent. 

[19] Man being one with God in his reality, a tiny fraction of the miraculous powers of Incarnations of God are shown by extraordinary men throughout the world. (See 240[12-13]) A yogi gave gratis a mantra to Giri Baalaa, a woman in India. Merely by imbibing air, it enabled her to live a normal life in a household. She did not take any food or liquid for fifty years. (Y 531) Therese Neumann, a peasant woman of Konnersreuth, South Germany, lived for thirty-five years without ingesting any liquid or food. Both women were intensely religious. (EFS 92) There are a few other such persons in recorded history. Similarly, psychic and supra-normal powers are a common experience. Cayce left over fourteen thousand psychic statements relating to thousands of people in the USA. (EFS 90-92) Jean Dixon predictions are well known in the USA. Ruth Montgomery (an investigative journalist and author) till a year ago provided documented evidence of miraculous healing, karma, rebirth and transference of the soul from one body to another, all in the late twentieth century in the USA. These extraordinary persons demonstrated selfless psychic powers of an unusual nature. (See 42[3, 6-13]) A little discrimination distinguishes a miracle from the magic of charlatans. To deny miracles by all human beings completely is to deny the Vedantic truth of the oneness in their reality of all with God and therefore some men's capacity to do some benign things sometimes that are inexplicable. Some manifest their oneness with God in their actions occasionally to a greater degree than others. To test manifestations in a miracle is valid. To reject then without testing is to perpetuate ignorance about God's ways of doing things through His creation. 

[20] Some believers in the imperceptible God can and do visualize Him in their heart as having a human form, such as a Hallowed Lord sitting on a glorious throne dispensing grace, who can respond in the human attributes of love, mercy and punishment but of a limitless order. This visualization is also natural for those who cannot imagine these human attributes in an imperceptible Godhead of their religion. For such believers, God's human Incarnation is necessary. This is because God is the personification of love for the experience of this love by these believers. This truth of Incarnations of God could be experienced in person by many Indian sages before the advent of the Vedas and of some Incarnations of God. The sages communicated their experience and how to have it, as their gift for its enjoyment by humanity. They did not leave their names in tradition or record. 

66    Chaupaayi:    Nija bhrama nahin samujha-yeen ajnaanee: Prabhu para moha dharahin jarha praaanee:: 
Jathaa gagana ghanapattala nihaaree: jhampay-u bhaanu kahahin kubichaaree:: Bk117

66. Shiva continued, "One who is himself under an illusion about Universal Consciousness as the Ultimate Reality or Godhead and its aspects, blames God for His attachment to His own creation which keeps Him under an illusion. That one is like a fool who thinks that clouds have deprived the sun of its lustre."

Hurt by his failures and misery, an ignorant man thinks that God is ignorant because He cannot see how much injustice and suffering He causes in the world. 

What is our illusion or ignorance? It is maya, which causes it; so, maya is also called ignorance. (See 237-239) To think that there is no such thing as God whatever way one may think about Him is ignorance. Ignorance has also these forms. To think that in reality I am my body with a name and an identifiable form. To think that I am an individual reality with my mind, thoughts, preferences and passions. To believe in 'I' and 'mine' as separate from all others in reality. To think that the end of happiness is sensuous enjoyment and in accumulating money, knowledge, comfort, name or fame. We are warned that when we think that we are the body and not its tenant, desires warp the path of work, greed that of worship and anger that of wisdom or knowledge. Desires for fulfilment generally make deeds selfish and not selfless. Greed makes worship mere propitiation of God for favours. Anger is the enemy of knowledge. If we live at the level of the physical body, we create physical and 'intellectual giants and moral pygmies.’ 

A common ignorance is to think that I am separate from God and am the doer of all my deeds independent of God. This ignorance is called the egotism of the doer. For example, if I do not earn for my family, it will starve to death. To be diligent in our duty to maintain the family is wisdom. To think that without me it will starve to death is ignorance. In this pride of the indispensable doer, we forget three observable phenomena. First. Death is invariable but starvation to death of the surviving family is not invariable. Second, we have no control on innumerable factors without which our effort can be fruitless. They make our effort tiny for success in earning for the family. Continuous earning is not a certainty and is not in our control. Third, under the law of karma every family member brings his fate. We are merely a means to provide him what he brought. If not we, someone else will provide it to him. The means are changeable but his survival is not changeable by our effort. That is in God's hands. Knowledge is to understand that not we, but God is the provider and preserver. As His instrument, we merely do our duty without any control on the survival of the family. 

To keep this knowledge in mind and do everything that comes to us as our duty to God corrects our perspective, removes our ignorance and frees us from its result. The result is in the form of our anxiety, worry, strain and suffering. These are in reality all consequences of our past acts. 

We have four states of experience, namely, the wakeful, the dream, the deep sleep and the state beyond these called tureeya. In the dream and the deep sleep states we are not as aware of our body, or of our 'I' or of our individuality as in the waking state. Tureeya is a state of inner consciousness and of unawareness of the outside. It is the sleepless sleep of advanced yogis referred to in 135. There is, however, an inspirer and a silent witness of our self within us throughout. The states are temporary but this witness is unchanging, continual and real. 

It is wisdom to know that this witness is Paramayshwara, our reality, in the form of our jeevaatmaa or soul. We are the embodiment of the soul, which is purity, love, bliss and power within. The real we are the soul or divinity within the body. That reality is one with all in God who pervades all. We are the imperishable soul in our perishable body and brain. To think that we are the body with a soul within is ignorance. Our identification of our reality with our body makes us forget the ever-present divinity within us. This identification limits us to the capacity which the body and brain possess. When we are convinced that we are the soul, we live in that conviction to receive the unlimited capacity of the soul beyond the capacity of our mind to make our mind perform the impossible. This is done through alignment of our intellect with our inmost self. (See  42[3, 6-13] and Geetaa 2:50-53) 

Merely to know that we are not the body but the inmost self is not enough. Mere knowing is not being. We have to experience this awareness for our conviction and then use it in our daily conduct in life. We do that by trying to live in righteousness and benevolence for all, which is in accord with our Satchidaananda dharma or our divinity. (See 242, 259) This living in our innate nature is being what we are. When this living puts us in control of our senses and passions and purifies our intellect to take our vision beyond dualities, that is, the feeling of 'I' and 'you' ceases, we gain Knowledge or realize the identity of our Self with Brahman or God within. Then we become what we are, namely, God. To concentrate upon our divine nature one with all men and God, is the aim of Sanaatana Dharma. Under the law of karma, what we give to others is to ourselves. Therefore our intent and conduct should always be benevolent and righteous. This is knowledge. 

These ideas that follow show our ignorance. To think that there is no God or that He lives in the far away heaven, beyond the reach of our sincere call. To think that He is not within everything, including us. To remain under the control of the six passions, which make us think that the worldly pleasures are real and are the be all and end all of our being. To harbour the pride of knowledge. (See 70

Knowledge and ignorance are always with us. It is in the same way that darkness disappears when the lamp is brought in and reappears when it is taken out. Ignorance as darkness did not come or go. It was there all the time. When we let slip our capacity to distinguish the real from the unreal, we become ignorant. (See 67

To treat the multiplicity of changing forms in the world as real and not understand that their underlying reality is one is ignorance. To deny our oneness with all in reality and not to act with love, that is, benevolence for all as one with us, is ignorance. Motivating all our acts by such love is living spiritually in our reality and divinity and is knowledge. 

Our overwhelming passions put us in the control of maya to make us ignorant of the true form of objects and to distort our perspective. Our greed sees a metal (gold) as precious, lust sees the opposite sex as an object for carnal desire, egotism sees others proud and faulty, and so on. (See 407) This ignorance caused by the power of our passions deprives us of discrimination, makes us blind to reality, attaches us to worldly pleasures and takes us away from continual bliss and God. Worldly attachment through passions is ignorance. (See 134

Our forgetting the law of karma also causes our ignorance. Not to make intelligent use of this law to invoke grace for our relief and prosperity is one of the main causes of suffering in the world. (See 185[2-8, 10, 11-13, 16, 19, 23, 24, 25]) 

To forget two things is ignorance. First. If we surrender to God in advance all that we do daily and also ourselves, He loves to remove our suffering to give us bliss. Second. His grace wipes out our faults, our attachment to past deeds and the impact upon us of their consequences in present suffering because He is supreme over Karma. (See 50, 325) This ignorance causes continuance of our suffering. In short, if we do not know ourselves and our relationship in reality with God and have no faith in that knowledge, we cannot know the cause of our problems and solutions available to free us from suffering. 

Ignorance has many forms. Each is created by one or more passions in us. For instance, our egotism calls the world imperfect with rampant misery, dualities of good and bad and of happiness and suffering. It is not possible to answer why God created an apparently imperfect world. Since dualities make the world imperfect, in a perfect world there should be no dualities even of the smallest difference. Everyone should have the same mind, capacity, tastes and intellect for getting equally what one wants by mere wishing or by identical effort with identical results. There can be no obstacles to fulfilment of wishes to cause unhappiness to some. Effort means hardship or unhappiness to some degree, so, the perfect world will be without any effort. 

So, in a perfect world, there will be neither effort nor any activity. Without unhappiness to compare it with, people will not know the kind of happiness and its qualities, gradations and height, which we experience in this imperfect world of differences and dualities. The perfect world becomes a couch potato world of no enjoyment of variety because variety arises from dualities, which in the present imperfect world cause unhappiness. Heaven, the abode of gods, may be the perfect world. No one returns from it to tell us about its manner of perfection and the nature of its bliss. Even heaven and hell imply dualities. The indescribable bliss of jnaana and samaadhi or tureeya is incommunicable. It is not for all. Both are experienced in, and so cannot exist without, the imperfect world. In the end, we realize that the apparently imperfect existing world is perfect for its role of making us all know true happiness, strive for it and enjoy it in the world itself. The cause of all forms of misery is ignorance. So it is removable to a large extent by our own knowledge and effort. 

Similarly, there is universal ignorance of the totality of factors or circumstances leading to an occurrence or our achievement. The knowledge of those factors is necessary to form correct premises for thought or action. A viewer of a movie knows all the occurrences around each actor. Each actor in the story does not know it. Hence is the play. So, our ignorance of the totality of our past and of the future makes possible our acting in the play of life and the continuance of the world. This ignorance is also called maya. It makes knowledge worth our striving for.


Previous                           Contents                              Next

Home

Dedication

Reviews

An Appeal

Author's Note

Arrangement of Book

Hindi Spellings

Table of Contents

Tribute to Gandhi

Introduction

The Raama Story

Philosophy

Baalakaandda

Ayodhyakaandda

Aranyakaandda

Kishkindhaakaandda

Sundarakaandda

Lankaakaandda

Uttarakaandda

Index

Glossary

Proper Names

Bibliography

Acknowledgments

Appendices

Ghazal

A-D

E-H

I-O

P-Z

A-L

M-Z

Appendix 1

Appendix 2

Appendix 3

Appendix 4